Mimesis Minecraft High-Integration Evidence Card - 2026-06-15
Mimesis Minecraft High-Integration Evidence Card - 2026-06-15
이 artifact는 mimesis-plugin private/local evidence card의 공개 가능한 요약이다.
목적은 “Mimesis가 Fable5-mc 수준에 가까워졌다"거나 “AI 시각 품질이 검증됐다"고 말하는 것이 아니다.
목적은 더 작다.
하나의 local high-integration voxel visual task에서 source artifact, baseline output, conditioned output, checklist control, gate/scorer, blind 3-judge panel, n=2 per cell, failure cases, claim boundary가 같은 evidence card 안에 들어갔음을 공개 가능한 형태로 남긴다.
따라서 이 페이지의 핵심 가치는 성과 과장이 아니라 승격 게이트다.
private/local note -> evidence card -> public-safe claim boundary
Current public level:
redacted local evidence card / not external validation / not L5 proof
Claim
Allowed public claim:
Digital Factory has a private/local Minecraft high-integration evidence card.
In that local card, artifact-level Mimesis was tested against a bare prompt
baseline, a checklist control, and a method-only ablation on one visual voxel
integration task.
The card records source, baseline, conditioned output, checklist control,
gate/scorer, blind 3-judge panel, n=2 per cell, failures, and banned claims.
Forbidden public claim:
- Mimesis has external validation.
- Mimesis generally improves visual quality.
- The output is near Fable5-mc.
- This is a public benchmark.
- The result is statistically significant.
- Human visual-quality proof exists.
- Mimesis beats checklist prompting in general.
- The private
mimesis-pluginrepo is public proof. - The local card gives legal clearance to reuse third-party source assets.
Verified Originals
These originals shape the evidence grammar. They do not validate this Mimesis output.
| source | why it is here | boundary |
|---|---|---|
| Angais/Fable5-mc | Public high-integration Minecraft-style source artifact used as an expert artifact reference. Observed via gh repo view as PUBLIC, default branch main, pushed 2026-06-09T21:39:45Z, 60 stars, no licenseInfo returned. | Source quality and integration density do not transfer validation, license rights, or output quality to the local Mimesis result. |
| OpenAI Evals | Maintained evaluation-harness precedent: tasks should have samples, scorers, and result records rather than only impressions. | Using an eval-like grammar does not make this a public benchmark. |
| Inspect | Evaluation should make tasks, solvers, scorers, logs, and analysis inspectable. | This artifact borrows the logging/scoring grammar only. |
| Model Cards for Model Reporting | Public AI documentation should state intended use, evaluation factors, metrics, and limitations. | This is not a model card and does not report a released model. |
| Datasheets for Datasets | Dataset-style documentation should explain motivation, composition, collection, uses, and maintenance. | This route borrows the documentation discipline only; it is not a dataset release. |
| W3C PROV | Provenance separates source entities, activities, and generated artifacts. | Provenance is not proof of correctness or quality. |
| ACM Artifact Review and Badging | Artifact claims should distinguish availability, evaluation, reproducibility, and validation. | This page is a redacted proof route, not an artifact badge or independent validation. |
| ML Reproducibility Checklist | Results should expose measures, run counts, variation, and compute context where possible. | The current card still has small-n and local-judge limits. |
| US10929110B2 | Prior-art pattern for evaluating user experience via tasks, evidence, and scoring. | Patent existence does not validate this local method. |
Evidence Card
Observed from the private/local Digital Factory/mimesis-plugin evidence lane after merge commit baf1b09fb6023eccf252a34890857ea1a517da43.
| field | value | public boundary |
|---|---|---|
| source artifact | Angais/Fable5-mc public repo was used as a high-integration reference artifact. | This is source inspiration and structure extraction, not license or quality transfer. |
| baseline output | The base model produced flat shells in the local task. | Baseline weakness does not prove the conditioned output is good in absolute terms. |
| conditioned output | Mimesis-conditioned output was compared against bare, checklist, and method-only conditions. | Local relative score is not public benchmark proof. |
| checklist control | A checklist-only control existed so “more instructions” could be separated from artifact-level conditioning. | The card does not prove Mimesis generally beats checklist prompting. |
| gate/scorer | The card used an explicit scoring/gate surface rather than only narrative judgment. | Scorer design is local and not externally validated. |
| blind 3-judge panel | Local card records a blind 3-judge panel. | This is not an external or statistically powered panel. |
| n=2 per cell | Each compared condition had two samples per cell. | Very small n; directional local evidence only. |
| failure cases | The card records that decomposition did not replicate the source and that board-v0 scoring did not include route-linked wrong-anchor evidence. Board v1 now has local screenshot sidecars, manifest-preflight.json, manifest-promotion-blockers.json, MANIFEST-CONTRACT.md, manifest.schema.json, board-v1-inspection-manifest.json, an aggregate transcript ledger, scorer-transcript-availability.json, README proof-gate surface, and a local wrong-anchor execution/render sidecar. | Failure visibility is stronger than hiding the weakness; the contract/schema preview, manifest promotion blocker index, inspection manifest, transcript availability audit, README proof surface, and sidecars are still not manifest.json, READY.json, route-linked board-v1 proof, public-safe screenshot manifest, or full per-judge transcript proof. |
| claim boundary | Forbidden claims include external validation, human visual-quality proof, near-Fable proof, public benchmark status, legal clearance, and universal lift. | This boundary is the main public asset of the card. |
What Changed
Before this card, the public profile could only say:
Evidence Card Contract exists as a private/local promotion gate.
Now the public site can say:
One private/local evidence card has been shaped into that contract and summarized publicly with explicit forbidden claims.
That is still a small claim. It does not turn the private repo into public proof. It only shows the local note did not jump straight into marketing copy.
Local Verification
External source snapshot command:
gh repo view Angais/Fable5-mc --json nameWithOwner,visibility,url,pushedAt,defaultBranchRef,licenseInfo,stargazerCount
Observed:
{"defaultBranchRef":{"name":"main"},"licenseInfo":null,"nameWithOwner":"Angais/Fable5-mc","pushedAt":"2026-06-09T21:39:45Z","stargazerCount":60,"url":"https://github.com/Angais/Fable5-mc","visibility":"PUBLIC"}
Private/local verification commands recorded after the evidence card merge:
cd <private-local-workbench>/mimesis-plugin
python verify_readme_claims.py
python verify_leaderboard_claims.py
python verify_claims.py
python verify_evidence_references.py
python tools/validate_module.py --all
git diff --check
cd <private-local-workbench>
python verify_workbench_surface.py
Observed result:
README/leaderboard/claims/evidence checks passed.
14/14 valid.
Digital Factory workbench surface checks passed.
Claim Boundary
What this artifact proves:
- A private/local Minecraft high-integration evidence card exists.
- The card uses the
Evidence Card Contractfields rather than only narrative self-praise. - The card records at least one baseline, one conditioned output, one checklist control, a local gate/scorer, local blind judging, small-n limits, failure cases, and forbidden claims.
- A public-safe summary route now exists for the card.
What this artifact does not prove:
- external validation,
- human visual-quality proof,
- public benchmark status,
- near-Fable output quality,
- statistical significance,
- legal clearance,
- production readiness,
- customer outcome,
- universal Mimesis lift,
- or that Mimesis generally beats checklist prompting.
Marketing Use
Safe sentence:
The first private/local Mimesis evidence card now has a public-safe summary: it shows source, baseline, conditioned output, checklist control, gate/scorer, failure cases, and forbidden claims before any marketing copy.
Unsafe sentence:
Mimesis proved it can generate Fable-level Minecraft visuals.
Weak Evidence Notes
| weak point | why it matters | current handling |
|---|---|---|
| private/local raw evidence | Reviewers cannot inspect the full private card from this public page. | Treat this as a redacted proof route, not public raw proof. |
| wrong-anchor sidecar not score-ready | A local wrong-anchor execution/render sidecar now exists, but it is not route-linked board-v1 proof and has no full per-judge transcript. | Keep route-linked wrong-anchor scoring evidence as the next required gate. |
| transcript availability audit is not a transcript | scorer-transcript-availability.json records that raw per-judge score rows, raw comments, disagreement/adjudication rows, and redaction-reviewed raw rows are still missing. | Treat it as a blocker audit, not as transcript proof. |
| manifest preflight is not a manifest | manifest-preflight.json records candidate rows, screenshot hashes, build logs, runtime-smoke refs, and aggregate scorer refs. | Do not call it manifest.json, READY.json, or a public-safe board-v1 package. |
| manifest promotion blocker index is not a waiver | manifest-promotion-blockers.json records why promotion is still blocked. | Do not call it manifest.json, READY.json, a public-safe manifest, or board-v1 readiness. |
| manifest contract/schema is not readiness | MANIFEST-CONTRACT.md and manifest.schema.json define the expected public-safe screenshot manifest shape. | Treat this as manifest contract/schema only; it is not a filled manifest.json, not READY.json, and not completed board-v1 proof. |
| inspection manifest is not readiness | board-v1-inspection-manifest.json indexes existing blocker/preflight records and unsupported claims. | Treat this as inspection-only evidence metadata; it is not manifest.json, not a public-safe screenshot manifest, not READY.json, and not completed board-v1 proof. |
| n=2 per cell | The sample size is far too small for statistical claims. | Say directional local evidence only. |
| local blind panel | The panel is recorded as local and small. | Do not call it external validation. |
source license unknown in gh repo view | licenseInfo returned null. | Do not imply reuse rights or legal clearance. |
| decomposition did not replicate | The conditioned output did not become the source artifact. | Do not claim near-Fable quality. |
Promotion Blockers
The private/local card now has a stricter next-artifact boundary:
evidence card -> public board spec -> redacted board draft -> verifier pass -> live route -> profile/blog copy
The next public artifact is specifically a public redacted board, not a louder version of this page.
Minimum board sections:
- source-use boundary,
- condition board,
- baseline, checklist control, wrong-anchor control, and conditioned arms,
- public-safe screenshot sidecars or links,
manifest.jsonafter the preflight is complete,- judge protocol,
- scorer transcript,
- failure record,
- claim boundary.
Current state:
public redacted board v0 exists; local screenshot sidecars, manifest-preflight.json,
manifest-promotion-blockers.json, MANIFEST-CONTRACT.md, manifest.schema.json, board-v1-inspection-manifest.json,
an aggregate transcript ledger,
scorer-transcript-availability.json, README proof-gate surface,
and a local wrong-anchor execution/render sidecar exist,
but they are not manifest.json, READY.json, route-linked board-v1 proof, public-safe screenshot manifest, or
a full per-judge scorer transcript
This means the promotion blockers are clearer, but the claim is not stronger.
Next Proof
The next stronger artifact is not a louder claim.
It is Mimesis Minecraft Public Redacted Board v0 with source-use boundary, condition board summary, aggregate scoring, failure record, and claim boundary.
Its next proof is narrower: turn the wrong-anchor sidecar into route-linked board-v1 scoring evidence, clear the current manifest-promotion-blockers.json conditions, promote the current MANIFEST-CONTRACT.md / manifest.schema.json preview into a real public-safe manifest.json and READY.json, add raw per-judge rows/comments, redaction-reviewed raw rows, fuller judge protocol, and route-linked board-v1 entries.
Until then, the public claim remains:
one private/local high-integration evidence card and one public redacted board v0 exist, and their strongest public value is the visible claim boundary.